Skip to main content

Testing the water with Acquia Search for Drupal

Acquia used the first day of DrupalCon DC as well as their corporate site to announce the availability of their new service via a public beta program, Acquia Search. Acquia Search is "based on the powerful Lucene and Solr technologies from the Apache project" and "creates a rich index of your site content".  While Apache Lucene and Apache Solr are "free" and open source, the implementation and maintenance of these products can be rather daunting.  Acquia wishes to solve this complexity problem by offering Solr search as a service in their Acquia Network.

Acquia Search Status on Acquia NetworkBefore the beta was available to the public, CMSReport.com was invited by Jacob Singh to join the private beta program to test and review Acquia Search. I have only been using Acquia Search for a week so I still have some learning to do in order to take full advantage of the advanced configuration options in Apache Solr.  Although I'm new to Apache Solr,  I have to say that from a website owner's perspective the implementation of Apache Search was extremely easy.  After I signed up for the service on the network, implementing Acquia Search within the Acquia Drupal CMS was just a matter of activating the appropriate modules and waiting for my content to be indexed by the server.  Acquia Search works straight "out of the box" and I couldn't have asked for anything simpler.

According to Acquia adding Acquia Search to your site gives you:

  • Faceted search – enabling your visitors to find what they're seeking more quickly with search filters
  • Results sorting - enabling your visitors to sort their results by date, type, author
  • Results weighting – allowing site owners to make some pages float higher in the results listing to improve ranking (providing more granular control than Drupal's default search weighting)
  • Content recommendations – suggest additional related content to visitors and increase their time on a site
  • Faster performance than Drupal's built-in search, improving user response times
  • And a long list of other great features we have planned

While potential customers of this service will likely come from various directions, I believe Acquia Search may become the product for enterprise customers to take a more serious look at Drupal and Acquia.  Enterprises have a difficult time delivering on the promise of Enterprise 2.0 to its people especially in the area of content management, social publishing, and search capabilities.  Jeff Whatcott, former Acquia employee, once blogged about the advantages of Drupal in the enterprise.

As I've reflected on this, I think we need to more effectively emphasize the flexibility, agility, and adaptability of Drupal. It is the breadth and depth of the module library and the community behind it that makes Drupal stand out. Drupal is nearly always up to date with the latest trends. It can be adapted to meet a multitude of special situations without lots of custom coding. Not so for most of the solutions I saw at this show. Many of these solutions fall apart when it comes to delivering on the specific requirements of individual teams and internal communities. Things like custom content types, feeds that span multiple content types, and custom views of content are problematic for many of the vendors I spoke with.

Acquia logoWhile these are all valid reasons for enterprises to look at Drupal, the reasons alone may not be enough to persuade enterprise users.  No matter the economic climate, enterprises typically are very slow to adopt new information systems into their business.  The issue really isn't that there are no good enterprise solutions out there (my readers can list a number of great open source and propriety content management solutions). Instead off-the-radar issue can keep enterprises away from implementing better products.  In the case of a CMS, I'm thinking of the unfunded cost an enterprise often experiences before they even make a purchase.  It has been my observation that enterprises must commit a lot of talent, time, and infrastructure just to implement enterprise software for real world testing and evaluation.  This is where Acquia and their search service steps in.

I know a number of companies that like what they see in Drupal but are reluctant to invest more resources into their Intranet infrastructure.  Acquia Search could very well be the solution enterprises have been seeking without all the messy evaluation and entry level costs.  It just doesn't make financial sense for a company needing the features provided by Apache Solr for their Drupal site to not consider Acquia's Search before providing that same products/service in-house.  Acquia is a quicker and cheaper path to introducing Apache Solr services in the enterprise.  This is why I think Acquia has a winner with Acquia Search as it should entice more Drupal and potential Drupal users to join the Acquia Network.

Additional information about Acquia Search can be found at the Acquia website.

Comments

#1 Any idea what the price will

Anonymous's picture

Any idea what the price will be for Acquia Search? Even a ballpark figure...

#2 Acquia Search price

Bryan's picture

As I'm not with Acquia, I have no idea what the price would really be. Acquia has a FAQ on your question though...

What does Acquia Search cost?

Acquia Search is free to all Acquia Network subscribers during the beta period. When the beta period ends (TBD), we expect that Acquia Search will be included for no additional cost in an Acquia Network subscription where the amount of content indexed and search queries processed would be limited at some level to be determined based on beta feedback. People who exceed the level included with subscriptions will have the option to increase the amount of content indexed and search queries processed. Of course this is all subject to change based on beta usage and feedback.

Obviously, Acquia is still testing the waters on their price model. I could see some site owners want the search, but perhaps not wanting to pay for the complete Acquia Network service.

#3 Acquia search pricing

Bryan House's picture

Bryan's correct, we are still investigating the costs to deliver Acquia Search as a hosted web service - this is one primary objectives for the beta program.

That said, Acquia Search will be included with all of our annual Acquia Network support subscriptions, which start at $199/year. We are also considering offering Search as a stand alone service for Drupal site owners who are not interested in a support subscription.

Bryan House
Marketing Director, Acquia

#4 Even if the price will be

ClarinetistulJohn's picture

Even if the price will be high at the beginning, it's best you wait for 3 months and then they'll have offers, like when they first introduced Drupal cms the same thing happened. I can't wait until it gets out.

#5 Solr search

Josh McCormack's picture

We implemented Solr for a high traffic client. Not only is the search high quality, and the related content very useful, but it removes a resource intensive function (search) from the rest of your Drupal site. I highly recommend it.

Josh McCormack
Owner, InteractiveQA
Drupal, Information Architecture and Quality Assurance
http://www.interactiveqa.com
917.620.4902

#6 Solr for multiple platforms?

Bryan's picture

Josh,

Have you ever had a client that wanted their Solr search to index not only Drupal sites but multiple Web applications. For example indexing both Drupal and MediaWiki? That's where I stumble on whether a Solr solution would be right for some implementations.

#7 That's exactly what Solr is good for

Jacob Singh's picture

Since Solr runs as a web service, it is really well suited for tasks like that.

The only issue is that you have to define a schema of fields which match up. MediaWiki and Drupal could have a shared schema, MediaWiki and Basecamp or MediaWiki and CiviCRM would be tougher to keep relevant.

We're going to introduce multisite search soon for Solr, but that's for multiple Drupal sites.

Best,
jacob

#8 Bryan, thanks for taking the

Anonymous's picture

Bryan, thanks for taking the time to review and write it up. Any idea whether Acquia search includes files/attachments?

#9 We're not currently

Jacob Singh's picture

We're not currently supporting file attachments, although it is at the top of our backlog, expect to see it in beta by Q3, but possibly production as well.

Best,
Jacob

Bryan's picture

About this CMS Enthusiast

Bryan Ruby is the owner and editor for CMS Report. He founded CMSReport.com in 2006 on the belief that information technologists, website owners, and web developers desired visiting sites where they could learn about content management systems without the sales pitch. Outside of his late night blogging hours, he is the Information Technology Officer for a field office in the federal government.